Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

Decision case · Saint Ignatius of Loyola

Instructing Papal Nuncios Sent to Embattled Ireland

Context

In September 1541, Pope Paul III sends two of your companions, Fathers Paschase Broët and Alfonso Salmerón, through Scotland into Ireland. They travel as papal nuncios, or ambassadors of the pope. Their mission is to encourage Irish chiefs, bishops, and Catholics pressured by King Henry VIII's break with Rome. They carry papal powers to grant dispensations, which are official exemptions from Church rules, and absolutions from penalties. In normal diplomatic practice, offices often collect fees or offerings for such papers. Under constant danger of capture, the priests must also deal with lords of very different tempers—some fiery, others suspicious. Greed will ruin the mission, and careless words will alienate local leaders. What rules will you give Broët and Salmerón on conversation and money?

Options

  • Order them to listen patiently, speak slowly, and adapt to each person's temper ('entering by their door to come out by ours'). Forbid them to touch a penny for papal dispensations, sending any alms straight to the poor.
  • Allow them to accept the usual office offerings for papal dispensations to pay for safe travel across Scotland and Ireland.
  • Direct them to avoid worldly lords altogether and preach only in secret across country parishes.

Choice

In Letters XII and XIII (September 1541), Ignatius directed Broët and Salmerón to speak slowly and carefully. They had to adapt to each person's temper, 'entering by their door to come out by ours'. They were never to touch a single coin for any papal dispensation, having others give any donations to the poor.

Consequence

Broët and Salmerón carried out their dangerous mission across Scotland and Ireland in early 1542. Throughout the journey, they kept these exact rules of wise speech and strict refusal of money.

Virtues: Prudence, Obedience, Humility

Evidence