Decision case · Saint Ignatius of Loyola
Responding to Heresy Accusations in Rome
Context
In 1538 you preach and give the Spiritual Exercises in Rome while your companions serve in Bologna, Ferrara, Padua, and Siena. A fierce campaign of slander suddenly breaks out against you in Rome. Critics claim you and your companions are secret heretics who fled punishment in Spain, Paris, and Venice. Powerful supporters pull back, and people grow afraid to attend your sermons. Providentially, several judges and church leaders who examined and cleared you in Spain, Paris, and Venice are now in Rome. Lingering suspicion of heresy, or false teaching rejected by the Church, will cripple your work across Italy. How will you answer these public charges?
Options
- Ask the Governor of Rome and Pope Paul III for an official court verdict of innocence. Make sure no shadow of heresy, or false teaching rejected by the Church, remains on your teaching.
- Let the accusers withdraw quietly without asking the Governor's court for a written verdict.
- Leave Rome for a university town in northern Italy until the uproar fades.
Choice
On 2 December 1538 (Letter IX), Ignatius reported the outcome to Monsignor Pietro Contarini. He and his companions went before the Governor and the Legate in Rome and insisted on a formal verdict. Witnesses from Spain, Paris, and Venice testified until both their teaching and their lives were officially declared blameless.
Consequence
Cleared by an official verdict in Rome, the companions returned to preaching and charity with greater fruit. They then offered their service to Pope Paul III.
Virtues: Fortitude, Prudence, Obedience
