Decision case · Saint Ignatius of Loyola
Answering a Nun Torn Between Slavish Fear and Dread of Pride
Context
In June 1536, you are studying theology in Venice while waiting for your companions from Paris. Sister Teresa Rejadella, a Benedictine nun at the reforming convent of Santa Clara in Barcelona, sends you a letter. She shares two opposite inner struggles. Sometimes she feels cut off from God, crushed by past sins, and unworthy to speak or receive Communion. At other times, God fills her with inner tears and spiritual joy, yet sudden fear whispers that these gifts are proud illusions. Meanwhile, harsh fasting and lost sleep are weakening her body. Giving in to false humility brings paralyzing sadness, while fearing God's comfort or ruining her health stops her progress. How will you guide Sister Teresa on both inner struggles and bodily penance?
Options
- Direct her to oppose each attack: trust God's mercy against false humility, and recall her faults thankfully during spiritual joy. Also instruct her to keep sleep and meals moderate.
- Warn her to distrust all tears and comfort as traps of pride, and order harsher fasts and night watches.
- Advise her to stop examining her inner thoughts altogether and rely only on outward convent routines.
Choice
Writing from Venice on 18 June 1536, Ignatius unmasked both extremes as traps of the spiritual enemy. When tempted by false humility and sadness, Sister Teresa had to oppose the enemy by resting in Christ's mercy. When God gave tears and joy and the enemy whispered fear of pride, she had to recall her faults humbly while thanking God. She also had to keep food, sleep, and penance moderate.
Consequence
Ignatius sent a follow-up letter on 11 November 1536 (Letter VI). His advice became classic guidance on telling good spiritual movements from bad ones in religious life.
Virtues: Discernment, Humility, Prudence
