Decision case · Saint Ignatius of Loyola
The Bell Rings for 'The Hall' at Sainte-Barbe
Context
At Sainte-Barbe College in Paris, your philosophy professor, Master Juan Peña, complained to the Principal, Dr. James Gouvea. Peña claimed your Sunday spiritual talks and confessions were distracting students from their logic lessons. Believing hostile rumors, Dr. Gouvea ordered a shameful public beating known as 'the hall'. In this punishment, all the professors beat a student with rods before the college as a corrupter of youth. The college bell is already ringing, and the rods are laid out. Personally, you gladly welcome blows and insults out of love for Christ. Yet if young students whom you recently led to confession see you branded a corrupter, their new faith may break. Keeping silent harms young converts, while angry protest breaks humility and obedience. How will you act as the bell rings?
Options
- Go straight to Principal Gouvea before the beating starts and state that you welcome blows for yourself. Calmly warn how branding you a corrupter will harm young students new to virtue.
- Submit silently to the rods without offering a single word of explanation.
Choice
Ignatius placed the spiritual good of others ahead of his own wish to suffer humiliation. He went straight to Dr. Gouvea, declared his readiness to suffer personally, and warned of the harm to young converts.
Consequence
Dr. Gouvea led Ignatius by the hand into the courtyard where the whole college waited. Kneeling in tears at Ignatius's feet, Gouvea begged pardon and declared aloud that a saint was living among them.
Virtues: Humility, Prudence, Fortitude
Evidence
- Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceIgnatius subordinated his personal desire for humiliation to the good of souls, went directly to Dr. Gouvea, stated his own readiness to suffer, and warned of the scandal to young converts. Dr. Gouvea led Ignatius by the hand into the courtyard where the whole college was waiting, fell on his knees at Ignatius's feet with tears, begged his pardon, and declared that a saint was living among them.
