Decision case · Saint Ignatius of Loyola
Guiding Souls According to Capacity Without Forcing Their Vocation
Context
Two people come to you for spiritual guidance. The first can make the full Spiritual Exercises and is weighing whether to leave his wealth for religious life. You view religious poverty as the higher path and feel tempted to push him toward it during his retreat. The second is an uneducated worker with little free time who sincerely wants to change his life. Some advisers urge you to give this worker all four weeks of deep meditations and life-choice exercises at once. How will you guide both people so God works freely with the first and the second is not overwhelmed?
Options
- Stand balanced like the pointer of a scale while the first person seeks God's will directly. Give the second only the daily conscience reviews, confession, and First Week prayers suited to his life.
- Press the first person to vow religious poverty during his retreat. Push the second through all four weeks of the Exercises despite his busy schedule.
Choice
In Annotation 15, Ignatius orders the retreat guide to stay balanced like a scale. In that way, the Creator deals directly with the person choosing a state of life. In Annotation 18, guides must fit the Exercises to each person's readiness. Busy or simpler people receive only the daily conscience reviews and First Week prayers.
Consequence
Outside the Exercises one may encourage religious life or unmarried chastity, yet during the retreat the guide must lean neither way (Annotation 15). Under Annotation 18, busy or unlettered people receive the Particular and General Examens, prayer methods, weekly confession, and First Week meditations without heavy election matters.
Virtues: Discernment of Spirits, Holy Indifference, Obedience
