Decision case · Saint Ignatius of Loyola
Refusing a Quiet Dismissal in Rome
Context
In Rome, a Spaniard named Mudarra and two followers of a secret Lutheran preacher bring false charges before the Governor's court. They claim you and your companions are fugitives whose likenesses were burned in Spain, Paris, and Venice. By God's providence, the very judges and witnesses from those cities happen to be in Rome right then. Dr. Ortiz, the Figueroa family, and Venetian nobles all testify completely in your favor. With your accusers defeated, the Papal Legate, the Governor of Rome, and even your friends want to drop the case quietly. Demanding a verdict will annoy powerful officials. Yet dropping the case without one leaves whispers of heresy, or false teaching rejected by the Church, over your preaching. Will you accept a quiet dismissal or ask Pope Paul III for an official verdict?
Options
- Object to dropping the case quietly and visit Pope Paul III in person at Tusculum. Ask him to order an official court sentence that puts the whole truth on public record.
- Agree to the wishes of the Legate and your friends by letting the charges be dropped quietly without an official verdict.
Choice
Ignatius objected to dropping the case quietly, even though this displeased the Legate, the judge, and his own supporters. He traveled in person to Pope Paul III at Tusculum and showed why an official court sentence was needed.
Consequence
Pope Paul III ordered a formal verdict. On 18 November 1538, the Governor of Rome publicly declared Ignatius and his companions innocent. That clear verdict opened the way for their Roman ministry and the approval of the Society of Jesus.
Virtues: Prudence, Fortitude, Obedience
