Decision case · Pope Saint Gregory I the Great
Forgiving Murderous Monks and Returning to Solitude
Context
After warning a neighboring community that his strict rule and their lax habits would not agree, you yielded to their pleas to serve as abbot; now they have tried to murder you with poisoned wine, which shattered when you blessed it with the sign of the Cross. How do you respond to the monks' attempt on your life and their unanimous refusal of reform? Preserving charity without anger while refusing to waste pastoral labor on an incurably rebellious community that plots murder.
Options
- Forgive the monks calmly without anger, remind them that you warned them their ways and yours would not agree, and return quietly to Subiaco where souls eager for God can bear fruit.
- Remain among the murderous monks to enforce outward compliance by coercion and angry reprisals.
Choice
Benedict rose with a calm and serene countenance. Then he gathered the community, prayed 'May God forgive you, brethren'. Reminded them that he had warned them from the beginning that their ways and his would not agree. He also assured them to seek a superior with whom they could live in peace. In addition, he returned quietly to his solitude at Subiaco.
Consequence
Through this decisive commitment, Pope Saint Gregory I the Great established an enduring witness for the Church.
Virtues: Prudence, Charity, Fortitude
