Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

Decision case · Saint Bernard of Clairvaux

The Lost Star at Jerusalem and the Spirit of Herod

Context

In your monastery, several young brothers are taking their first steps with fresh, eager love for God. At the same time, cynical voices grumble against these beginnings and urge you to crush them early. Others press you to bend your spiritual mission to the political schemes of powerful patrons. When the Magi turned aside to ask directions at King Herod's court in Jerusalem, they immediately lost sight of the star. Crushing young religious zeal imitates Herod, while trusting worldly courts leaves the soul in darkness. How will you treat worldly politics and young beginnings of devotion?

Options

  • Reject 'the spirit of Herod' by protecting and encouraging fresh efforts at holiness in their infancy. Leave worldly courts behind to follow God's star straight to the humble manger with gold, frankincense, and myrrh.
  • Hold back and crush new beginnings of religious zeal while looking to worldly courts for guidance.

Choice

In Sermon II on the Epiphany, Bernard warned that crushing early efforts toward holiness shares in 'the malice of a Herod'. He also pointed out that the Magi regained the star and overflowing joy the moment they left Herod's court behind.

Consequence

Entering the poor house without taking offense at its poverty, the Magi worshiped the Child and offered gold, frankincense, and myrrh.

Virtues: Prudence, Humility, Charity

Evidence