Decision case · Saint Bernard of Clairvaux
Writing the 'Missus Est' Homilies from the Infirmary
Context
Illness temporarily keeps you in the monastery infirmary, away from field work and daily preaching to your fellow monks. In this rare quiet, you long to write sermons praising the Virgin Mother. They would meditate on Saint Luke's story of the Annunciation ('Missus est angelus Gabriel'). Yet Cistercian custom frowns on private literary display undertaken without a request from the community. Staying idle wastes a rare season for prayer, while writing like a boastful scholar could trouble your brothers. How will you use your infirmary rest and present these sermons?
Options
- Use your infirmary rest to write four sermons praising the Virgin Mother on Luke 1:26–38. Add an honest preface confessing that personal devotion moved you while sickness prevented field labor.
- Hold back from writing altogether until your health returns and you can give ordinary spoken sermons again.
Choice
Bernard used his rest in the infirmary to compose the four Homilies on the 'Missus Est' (De Laudibus Virginis Matris). In a humble preface, he noted that personal devotion moved him to write while illness kept him from manual work.
Consequence
These four sermons include the famous 'Star of the Sea' prayer and a vivid meditation on Mary's 'yes' to God. They became the best-loved sermons on Mary in the Middle Ages.
Virtues: Humility, Charity, Prudence
Evidence
- Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceBernard used his infirmary rest to write the four Homilies on the 'Missus Est' (De Laudibus Virginis Matris), prefacing them with a humble explanation that his own devotion moved him to write while bodily sickness kept him from manual labor. The four homilies—containing the 'Star of the Sea' prayer and the dramatic meditation on Mary's fiat—became the most celebrated Marian homilies of the Middle Ages.
