Decision case · Saint Bernard of Clairvaux
The Papal Chancellor's Question
Context
You are Bernard, Abbot of Clairvaux, answering Lord Haimeric, Cardinal Deacon and Chancellor of the Roman See. Until now, Haimeric wrote from Rome only to ask for monastic prayers, never to pose theological questions. Now he turns from busy administrative work to ask a great spiritual question: why and how much God should be loved. You rejoice to see a high Roman official seeking spiritual counsel, yet his request puts you in a delicate spot. Your Cistercian vows bind you to humble prayer and penance rather than public scholarly debate. You consider yourself weak even at prayer, and you lack the scholarly training needed for hard theological problems. Yet both learned men and simple men offer the same excuse of inability when asked to write. Complete silence might make you look like a proud philosopher hiding behind grave reserve. Yet becoming Haimeric's ongoing advisor for future theological puzzles would overstep your monastic calling.
Options
- Share what you can from your humble store on loving God, since that topic is sweet, safe, and helpful. Refuse to promise answers to harder questions, leaving those to wiser men.
- Keep strict silence and decline to write at all, pleading your monastic vows and lack of scholarly training.
- Accept an ongoing role as Haimeric's theological advisor and promise to solve whatever doctrinal questions he sends from Rome.
Choice
Bernard chose to share what he could from his humble store on the single question of loving God. That theme is sweetest, safest to handle, and most helpful to the soul. At the same time, he refused to promise answers to harder questions and urged Haimeric to save those for wiser men.
Consequence
Answering this one question within monastic limits, Bernard composed On Loving God (De Diligendo Deo) for Cardinal Haimeric. In it he showed why God Himself is the reason for loving God and why love for Him knows no limit.
Virtues: Humility, Charity, Prudence
Evidence
- Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceWhen Cardinal Haimeric, Deacon of the Roman Church and Papal Chancellor, asked Bernard of Clairvaux to solve theological questions rather than merely pray for him, Bernard composed On Loving God (De Diligendo Deo) on why and how God should be loved while declining to promise answers to harder questions better left to wiser men.
