Decision case · Saint Augustine of Hippo
Preserving the Witness of Contemporary Miracles at Hippo
Context
Skeptics across North Africa ask why miracles no longer happen as they did in New Testament times. In truth, striking healings are occurring right in your diocese and nearby cities. These include Innocentia’s cure from breast cancer at Carthage—kept quiet until your rebuke—and cures at Saint Stephen’s Shrine in Hippo. Unlike Scripture, which churches read aloud year after year, recent local cures are quickly forgotten even by neighbors. Silent believers let God’s works fade from memory, while sloppy rumors ruin Christian credibility.
Options
- Rebuke healed believers who hide God’s mercy, collect written statements (libelli), read them aloud with witnesses present, and share copies.
- Leave modern healings unrecorded on the ground that only the biblical Scriptures should be read aloud.
Choice
At Hippo, Augustine required healed believers to write signed accounts (libelli). Priests read them aloud while the witnesses stood in full view on the sanctuary steps. He also preserved twenty-five verified miracles in Book XXII, Chapter 8 of The City of God.
Consequence
On Easter morning, Paul of Caesarea was healed at Saint Stephen’s Shrine. Augustine presented him before the church to hear his written report, and during that reading his sister Palladia was healed too.
Virtues: Prudence, Perseverance
