Decision case · Saint Augustine of Hippo
Answering the Platonists on Mediators and Sacrifice
Context
In Books I–VII you refuted popular and state worship of many gods through Varro and Seneca. Now you face Christianity’s sharpest philosophical rivals: the Platonists (Plato, Plotinus, Porphyry, and Apuleius). Unlike materialists, they already recognize one supreme, non-physical God who creates all things and lights up the mind. Yet Plato held that no god mixes directly with humans. On that basis, Apuleius urges sacrifices to spirits in the air, while Porphyry wavers over magic while seeking a universal path for the soul. Condemning Platonists completely drives away sincere truth-seekers, whereas allowing sacrifices to lesser spirits betrays worship owed to God alone.
Options
- Praise Platonists for knowing the spiritual Creator, then prove stormy demons cannot mediate, angels refuse worship, and Christ alone is Mediator.
- Allow lesser sacrifices to go-between spirits while merely swapping Christian angels in place of pagan spirits.
Choice
Augustine honored the Platonists above other philosophers for recognizing the non-physical Creator. Across Books VIII–X, he proved that Apuleius’s stormy demons are fallen spirits and holy angels refuse divine worship (latria). Christ the God-man alone is the true Mediator and Universal Way that Porphyry sought.
Consequence
Books VIII–X became early Christianity’s classic study of natural knowledge of God, angels, Christ’s unique mediation, and true inward and Eucharistic sacrifice.
Virtues: Prudence, Courage, Humility
