Decision case · Saint Augustine of Hippo
The Origin of Evil and the Goodness of the Body
Context
Starting Part II of The City of God on the two cities, you meet two rival claims about evil and bodily pain. Manichaeans claim an evil dark nature actively causes sin and physical matter. Platonists and followers of Origen claim God first made pure spirits alone. In Origen’s view, God later built physical bodies as prisons for souls that sinned in an earlier life. Giving the first evil choice an active maker blames God or invents an evil substance. Treating bodies as prisons slanders creation and bodily resurrection.
Options
- Prove every creature is good, show evil will had only a 'deficient cause' like darkness, and note the bodiless devil refutes Origen.
- Adopt Origen’s claim that souls sinned in an earlier spiritual world and received physical bodies as prison sentences.
Choice
In Books XI–XII, Augustine proved that all spiritual and bodily creatures are good and bear traces of the Trinity. An evil will has no active maker, only a 'deficient cause' (causa deficiens). Origen’s prison-body claim also fails because the devil, the worst sinner, has no earthly body.
Consequence
Augustine’s account of deficient causality in moral evil and the goodness of bodily creation became the standard Western Christian teaching on Creation and the Fall.
