Decision case · Saint Augustine of Hippo
The Doubtful Rhetorician Between Three Schools at Milan
Context
After nine years among the Manichees at Thagaste, Carthage, and Rome, you arrive in Milan as city professor of rhetoric under Prefect Symmachus. Back at Carthage, the famous Manichean bishop Faustus could not explain why astronomers predict eclipses accurately while Mani’s books tell false star fables. Discouraged in Rome, you nearly agreed with the Academic skeptics, philosophers who claimed nobody can reach sure truth. In Milan, Bishop Ambrose welcomes you kindly, and you attend his sermons to judge his speaking style. Listening closely, you hear him unlock hard Old Testament passages spiritually and answer Manichean mockery with strong arguments. You still cannot picture a spirit without physical bulk, yet secular philosophers clearly beat Mani on nature while lacking Christ’s saving Name.
Options
- Leave the Manichees, refuse soul-healers who lack Christ’s Name, and enroll as a Catholic catechumen until clear truth shines.
- Stay inside the Manichean sect despite your doubts until you find another teaching that is completely certain.
- Entrust your soul’s healing to secular philosophers and Academic skeptics because their science of nature beats Manichean fables.
Choice
Augustine left the Manicheans, judging it wrong to stay in a sect weaker than ordinary philosophy on natural truth. At the same time, he refused to trust his soul to philosophers who lacked the saving Name of Christ. Instead, he enrolled as a catechumen in his parents’ Catholic Church while waiting for sure light.
Consequence
Leaving Manicheism and entering the Catholic catechumenate in Milan prepared Augustine for the next steps of grace. There he welcomed Monnica, kept hearing Ambrose preach, and soon grasped spiritual reality and Christ’s humble mediation.
Evidence
- Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceAt Milan, after Bishop Ambrose’s spiritual explanations of the Old Testament answered Manichean objections, Augustine decided to leave the Manichees, refused to entrust his soul to secular philosophers who lacked the Name of Christ, and enrolled as a catechumen in the Catholic Church until sure light should appear.
