Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

Decision case · Saint Augustine of Hippo

Midnight by the Vineyard Wall

Context

Your schooling has paused for a full year at Thagaste after your return from nearby Madaura. Your father, a town citizen of modest means and high hopes, is saving money to send you to Carthage. With no classes and loose discipline at home, you spend idle days and nights with rowdy young companions. Among them, the loudest braggarts win the highest praise. Ashamed of seeming less daring or more chaste than your peers, you have even invented sins you never committed. Tonight your gang has roamed the town squares until midnight. Next to your family’s vineyard stands a neighbor’s pear tree heavy with dull, unappealing fruit. You are not hungry, and far better pears sit at home. Suddenly your friends urge everyone to climb over, strip the tree, and haul away pears just to laugh at the tricked owner.

Options

  • Join the gang in shaking and stripping the pear tree simply for the shared laugh and thrill of a forbidden act.
  • Refuse to join the theft and walk home alone, since you neither need poor pears nor enjoy stealing by yourself.
  • Offer to bring your companions better fruit from your own family’s storeroom instead of robbing the neighbor.

Choice

Augustine went along with his companions at midnight and shook and stripped the neighbor’s pear tree. Together the boys carried off heavy loads of pears, tasted only a few, and threw the rest to the pigs.

Consequence

Years later, a repentant Augustine saw that midnight theft as sinning for no material gain. Unlike ordinary thieves or plotters like Catiline, Augustine did not even want those poor pears. Breaking God’s law offered a crooked imitation of divine freedom. False group friendship pulled him into a crime he never would have done alone.

Virtues: Humility, Justice

Evidence