Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

Decision case · Saint Augustine of Hippo

The Conscientious Judge and the Darkness of Earthly Courts

Context

You must preside as judge over a death-penalty trial where the accused person may well be innocent. Because no judge can see inside another person’s conscience, Roman court law questions witnesses and defendants under torture to uncover facts. In mortal life’s painful darkness, an innocent prisoner sometimes confesses falsely just to stop the rack and is executed before the truth comes out. Deserting the judge’s bench abandons society’s peace. Yet Stoic bragging that earthly justice brings calm happiness ignores the tragedy of condemning the innocent unknowingly.

Options

  • Take your seat on the bench because deserting society is wrong, while grieving over courtroom darkness and praying, 'Deliver me from my necessities!'
  • Refuse to sit on the judge’s bench and abandon public civic duties altogether.

Choice

In Book XIX, Chapter 6, Augustine ruled that the wise judge takes his seat because deserting human society is wicked (nefas). Rejecting proud Stoic calm, the upright judge grieves over the blindness of earthly courts and cries out to God: 'Deliver me from my necessities!'

Consequence

In Book XIX, Chapter 17, Augustine widened this rule for God’s pilgrim City. Christians obey and serve civil laws that guard earthly peace in every nation whenever those laws do not block true religion.

Virtues: Justice, Prudence, Humility

Evidence