Decision case · Saint Augustine of Hippo
The Augur's Offer Before the Contest
Context
Between ages nineteen and twenty-eight, you earn your living teaching rhetoric, the craft of winning arguments with polished speech. At the same time you chase applause in the theater, prize poems, and victory crowns. Secretly you belong to the Manichean sect, imagining God as a shining physical body and fearing even to pluck plants or kill animals. Now you enter a public theater poetry contest where victory before the magistrates would boost your fame. Before the contest begins, a pagan fortune-teller, called an augur, sends word to you. He asks what fee you will pay him to guarantee first prize. To win help from his spirits, the fortune-teller plans to slaughter living animals and offer their blood to demons on your behalf.
Options
- Reject the fortune-teller’s offer flatly, declaring that not even for an immortal crown of gold may one fly be killed for your win.
- Name a fee and hire the fortune-teller to sacrifice living animals so his spirits secure the theater prize.
- Refuse blood sacrifices of animals, yet ask him to predict the winner through bloodless star charts instead.
Choice
Detesting those cruel rites, Augustine rejected the fortune-teller’s messenger at once. Not even for a crown of immortal gold, Augustine answered, would a single fly be sacrificed to buy his victory.
Consequence
Augustine competed without blood sacrifices and still won the theater crown from Proconsul Vindicianus, a wise old physician. Later in life, Augustine admitted that this refusal did not yet come from pure love of the true spiritual God. At that time he still pictured God as a shining body and still consulted astrologers.
Evidence
- Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceWhen an augur offered to guarantee Augustine victory in a theatrical poetry contest for a fee by sacrificing living creatures to demons, Augustine rejected the offer, declaring that not even for a crown of immortal gold should a single fly be sacrificed to buy his victory.
