Decision case · Saint Augustine of Hippo
The Assessor and the Senator's Unlawful Decree at Rome
Context
You are a young lawyer from Thagaste serving in Rome as legal adviser to the Count of the Italian Treasury. Your strict honesty already surprises fellow officials, because you find it strange when anyone prefers gold over fairness. Now a mighty Roman senator steps before the court. Many citizens owe him favors, and many more fear his vast wealth and power to help or ruin people. Used to getting his way, the senator demands a court decree that the law forbids. The presiding judge dislikes the illegal demand, yet fears refusing the senator to his face. Instead, the judge blames you, claiming his legal adviser refuses to let the decree pass. The senator first offers you a bribe and then threatens you.
Options
- Scorn the bribe, defy the threats, and hold firm, making clear you will resign if the judge signs the illegal decree.
- Take the bribe and approve the illegal decree, copying officials who trade honesty for gold and powerful friends.
- Refuse the money for yourself, yet quietly drop your objection so the frightened judge can sign without your resignation.
Choice
Alypius rejected the unlawful request, scorned the bribe, and stood firm against the senator’s threats. Even after the judge shifted the blame onto him, Alypius stood ready to walk out of court rather than allow an illegal decree.
Consequence
Observers marveled at Alypius’s courage in neither courting the favor nor fearing the anger of so mighty a senator. Soon afterward he also refused to copy personal books at state expense, proving a faithfulness that later served the Church beside Augustine.
Evidence
- Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceServing as legal Assessor to the Count of the Italian Bounty Office at Rome, Augustine’s friend Alypius refused an unlawful decree demanded by a powerful Roman senator, scorned a bribe, defied threats, and stood ready to leave the court rather than allow the decree.
