Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

Decision case · Saint Thomas Aquinas

Why Preachers Must Not Claim to Prove the Trinity by Philosophy Alone

Context

Eager preachers plan to tell non-Christian philosophers that natural human reason alone can strictly prove the three Persons of the Trinity from created things. They hope to treat comparisons about self-sharing goodness as ironclad proofs. How will you draw the line between natural reason and revealed faith?

Options

  • Forbid claiming natural reason strictly proves the Trinity, holding it by divine revelation and using analogies only to answer objections.
  • Insist that natural philosophy alone proves the three Divine Persons from creation and treat likely comparisons as strict proofs.

Choice

Natural reason knows God only from created works. Creative power belongs to the whole Trinity as one Essence, so reason proves only God’s one Essence. Weak claims to prove the Trinity expose Christian faith to unbelievers’ scorn.

Consequence

Through this decisive commitment, Thomas Aquinas established an enduring witness for the Church.

Virtues: Faith, Sacred Doctrine, Wisdom

Evidence