Decision case · Saint Thomas Aquinas
Why Ruining One's Health Is Insensibility, Not Temperance
Context
A zealous young friar cuts back food and sleep so harshly that his health is collapsing and he can neither study nor preach. Even so, he claims any care for nourishment or rest gives in to gluttony. How will you set straight his view of temperance, fasting, and right reason?
Options
- Show that temperance measures food by health and duty, so wrecking needed strength is the fault of insensibility, not virtue.
- Praise his self-destructive starvation as supreme temperance even though it ruins his ability to serve.
Choice
Temperance never wrecks human nature. Right reason measures food and rest by the real needs of health and daily duty. Refusing needed care is the vice of insensibility; as Jerome warned, offering God a ruined body offends reason.
Consequence
Through this decisive commitment, Thomas Aquinas established an enduring witness for the Church.
Virtues: Temperance, Chastity, Humility
