Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

Decision case · Saint Thomas Aquinas

Prophetic Wonders Versus Sanctifying Charity

Context

Townspeople crowd after a gifted wandering preacher who makes striking predictions and claims wonders. Although he lives in open pride and strife, people insist anyone with such gifts must be a saint. How will you help believers tell apart outward ministry gifts—called gratuitous graces—from the sanctifying grace and love that make a person holy?

Options

  • Show that prophecy and wonders are outward gifts given to help others, whereas personal holiness requires charity, humility, and obedience.
  • Declare that anyone who speaks prophecies or works wonders automatically possesses holy charity and cannot be in grave sin.

Choice

Outward gifts like prophecy, tongues, and miracles are gratuitous graces given to help the Church. Even sinners like Balaam and Caiaphas exercised them (Matthew 7:22). True personal holiness lives in sanctifying grace working through charity and humility.

Consequence

Through this decisive commitment, Thomas Aquinas established an enduring witness for the Church.

Virtues: Charity, Contemplation, Obedience

Evidence