Decision case · Saint Thomas Aquinas
Turning Mourning from Worldly Display to True Help for the Dead
Context
A wealthy citizen dies in God’s friendship, yet still owes cleansing in Purgatory for past sins. His heirs plan to spend nearly the whole estate on a grand parade, rich hangings, and a tall monument. Hoping to show off family rank, they think a lavish burial comforts the dead soul directly. As a result, they leave almost nothing for Masses, prayers, and alms for the poor. How will you guide the heirs toward suffrages—works that truly relieve souls in Purgatory?
Options
- Show that funeral display comforts only the living unless it stirs prayer, and direct funds to Masses, prayers, and alms for the poor.
- Approve the costly monument as direct spiritual relief in Purgatory and call alms for the poor unnecessary.
Choice
In Supplement Question 71 (Articles 9 and 11), the Mass, prayers, and almsgiving directly relieve souls in Purgatory. Funeral pomp and monuments comfort only the living unless they stir believers to pray and give alms.
Consequence
Citing Saint Augustine, Thomas holds that the Sacrifice of the Altar, prayer, and alms are the three chief helps for the dead. Burial in sacred ground helps indirectly by prompting prayer, whereas vain display helps the departed soul nothing at all.
Virtues: Sacred Doctrine, Hope, Mercy to the Dead
