Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

Decision case · Saint Thomas Aquinas

Why We Pray to an Unchanging God

Context

Students swayed by ancient fatalism claim that asking God for anything in prayer makes no sense. If God has decreed from eternity what will happen, prayer cannot change His mind; if not, asking is useless. How will you defend the real power of petitionary prayer without denying God’s unchanging wisdom?

Options

  • Show that we pray not to change God’s eternal plan, but to fulfill the very cause through which God wills to give blessings.
  • Claim either that human prayers force God to change His eternal mind or that asking accomplishes nothing beyond soothing feelings.

Choice

Divine providence decrees not only what results will happen, but also what causes bring them about. God ordains harvests through planted seed. In the same way, He ordains from eternity to grant certain graces through devout human prayer.

Consequence

Through this decisive commitment, Thomas Aquinas established an enduring witness for the Church.

Virtues: Religion, Devotion, Reverence

Evidence