Decision case · Saint Thomas Aquinas
True Prudence Versus Deceitful Craftiness
Context
Young merchants in a city guild admire a rich trader who uses shady legal tricks and deceit to outwit buyers. Because his schemes enrich his household, they praise his cleverness as the highest prudence. How will you separate the true virtue of prudence from counterfeit craftiness?
Options
- Show that true prudence requires both a good goal and honest means, while crooked schemes for profit are the vice of craftiness.
- Agree that any clever trick that wins wealth or worldly safety counts as the virtue of prudence.
Choice
True prudence is right reason in human action. It requires both a morally good goal and honest, truthful means. Plotting crooked paths—even toward a good goal—is the counterfeit sin of craftiness (astutia), turning cleverness against justice.
Consequence
Through this decisive commitment, Thomas Aquinas established an enduring witness for the Church.
Virtues: Prudence, Justice, Honesty
