Decision case · Saint Thomas Aquinas
Why God Never Forgives One Mortal Sin Without All the Others
Context
A rich penitent comes to Confession sorry for a burst of anger that scared him during an illness. Yet he openly refuses to leave an unlawful relationship or pay back stolen property, asking absolution for his anger alone. How will you guide him toward real contrition that restores friendship with God?
Options
- Show that mortal sin is forgiven only by sanctifying grace and love, requiring repentance from every mortal sin and repayment of stolen goods.
- Grant partial absolution for the anger alone while letting him cling willfully to his other mortal sins.
Choice
No mortal sin is ever pardoned without sanctifying grace and charity uniting the soul to God. Because nobody can be God’s friend and enemy at once, one mortal sin cannot be forgiven while the will clings to another.
Consequence
Through this decisive commitment, Thomas Aquinas established an enduring witness for the Church.
Virtues: Penance, Contrition, Mercy
