Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

Decision case · Saint Thomas Aquinas

Why a Sinful Minister Does Not Make Sacraments Invalid

Context

Parishioners learn that their local priest lived in secret mortal sin for years. Heartbroken, they fear all the Masses, baptisms, and confessions he celebrated for them were empty and invalid. How will you save them from despair and the old Donatist error while upholding the holiness required of priests?

Options

  • Reassure them that while an unworthy priest sins gravely, sacraments he validly celebrates remain fruitful because Christ Himself gives the grace.
  • Tell the parishioners that a priest’s secret mortal sin destroys sacramental grace and makes all their sacraments invalid.

Choice

A minister who celebrates sacraments while in mortal sin commits grave sacrilege himself. Still, sacraments he validly celebrates remain true and fruitful. He acts only as an instrument, while Christ the High Priest gives grace inwardly.

Consequence

Through this decisive commitment, Thomas Aquinas established an enduring witness for the Church.

Virtues: Fidelity, Justice, Religion

Evidence