Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

Decision case · Saint Thomas Aquinas

Why Each Human Person Has an Individual Thinking Soul

Context

University students report a philosophy lecturer claiming the whole human race shares one single intellect outside individual people. Under that view, individual people neither own an immortal soul nor answer personally after death. From experience and sound philosophy, how will you prove each person has an individual thinking soul?

Options

  • Prove that because this individual person both thinks universal truths and senses bodily things, each person owns an individual thinking soul.
  • Concede that all humans share one separate intellect that merely borrows individual human imaginations for a short time.

Choice

Experience proves plainly that 'this individual person understands' (hic homo intelligit). The thinking soul is therefore the inner life-principle (substantial form) of each person’s own body. Otherwise Socrates would no more think than a wall sees, destroying moral responsibility.

Consequence

Through this decisive commitment, Thomas Aquinas established an enduring witness for the Church.

Virtues: Wisdom, Understanding, Justice

Evidence