Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

Decision case · Saint Thomas Aquinas

Wise Limits of Civil Law and Obeying God Rather Than Men

Context

In a Christian land, strict reformers demand that civil courts punish every minor fault as a crime. At the same time, a secular ruler issues a decree ordering an act against God’s commandment and demands total obedience. How will you define what civil law should forbid and when citizens must refuse a ruler’s command?

Options

  • Hold that civil law forbids chiefly grave harms to lead imperfect citizens gradually, while any command against God’s law must be refused.
  • Demand that civil courts punish every small fault equally and that citizens obey rulers even against God’s commandments.

Choice

Human law governs imperfect citizens and forbids chiefly grave harms against neighbors and peace. In that way it leads people toward virtue step by step. Citizens may bear unfair burdens for peace. Yet any decree against God’s law must be refused, obeying God rather than men (Acts 5:29).

Consequence

Through this decisive commitment, Thomas Aquinas established an enduring witness for the Church.

Virtues: Justice, Prudence, Charity

Evidence