Decision case · Saint Thomas Aquinas
Defending How Human Teachers Truly Help Students Learn
Context
At a university debate, some scholars quote Matthew 23 and Augustine’s De Magistro to claim human teachers never truly cause learning. One side claims students already know everything before birth (Plato), while another claims an outside mind pours science into passive heads (Averroes). How will you uphold both God as inner Teacher and the real work of human teachers?
Options
- Show God alone gives reason’s inner light, while human teachers truly guide students step by step from known truths to new conclusions.
- Agree that human teachers never cause real learning because students already possess all science before birth.
Choice
While God alone plants the inner light of reason, human teachers act as real secondary causes of learning. Like doctors helping the body heal itself, teachers guide the student’s own mind from first truths to new conclusions.
Consequence
In First Part Question 117, Article 1, Thomas separates inward and outward teaching. God alone lights up the soul from within, whereas human teachers genuinely foster science from without through ordered signs and examples.
Virtues: Trust in Divine Providence, Wisdom, Docility to Truth
