Decision case · Saint Thomas Aquinas
The Limits of Obedience and the Higher Rule of Equity
Context
A city magistrate asks whether conscience binds him to obey a superior’s order or a written law during a sudden crisis. In that unforeseen emergency, obeying literally would either break God’s law or bring grave harm on innocent citizens. How will you define the limits of obedience and the role of equity (epikeia)?
Options
- Rule that no human authority may be obeyed against God’s law, and in sudden danger equity follows the lawmaker’s just purpose.
- Demand blind obedience to every superior’s order and every literal statute regardless of God’s law or public harm.
Choice
Citizens owe obedience to human rulers only within lawful authority and must never obey any command against God. Because general human laws cannot foresee every crisis, equity (epikeia) sets aside bare words when literal obedience would harm justice.
Consequence
Through this decisive commitment, Thomas Aquinas established an enduring witness for the Church.
Virtues: Fortitude, Equity, Perseverance
