Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

Decision case · Saint Thomas Aquinas

Defending Preaching Orders and Guiding Young Religious Vocations

Context

University critics attack your Dominican priory on two counts. First, they claim friars who study, teach, and preach in cities rank lower than strictly enclosed monks. Second, they want young students barred from entering religious life until they practice virtue for years in the world and win rich parents’ consent. From Questions 188 and 189 of the Secunda Secundae, how will you answer?

Options

  • Show that orders sharing contemplated truth by preaching hold top rank, and beginners may enter religious life without opposing relatives’ consent.
  • Concede that preaching orders rank lowest and send young recruits home until their wealthy families agree.

Choice

Religious orders that contemplate divine truth and share it through preaching and teaching hold the highest rank among religious communities. Furthermore, newcomers may enter religious life as a school of virtue without waiting for opposing relatives to agree.

Consequence

In Secunda Secundae Question 188, Article 6, lighting up others with contemplated truth outranks shining for oneself alone, matching Christ and the Apostles. In Question 189 (Articles 1 and 10), religious life trains beginners in holiness without interference from hostile kin.

Virtues: Justice, Fortitude, Humility

Evidence