Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

Decision case · Saint Thomas Aquinas

Overcoming Faintheartedness and Using Wise Sense in Fasting

Context

Two penitents ask your counsel. First, a gifted, holy priest shrinks from an urgent preaching mission requested by his bishop, calling his timid refusal 'humility'. Second, a poor stonemason doing exhausting labor all day to feed his young family is fainting during the Lenten fast. Still, he fears eating enough food to work would be a mortal sin. How will you counsel both men?

Options

  • Warn the priest that burying God-given gifts is faintheartedness (pusillanimity), and assure the exhausted mason heavy family labor excuses fasting.
  • Praise the priest’s timid refusal as deep humility, and order the fainting stonemason to fast until he collapses.

Choice

Shrinking out of fear from great good suited to one’s God-given gifts is the sin of pusillanimity, or faintheartedness. Meanwhile, heavy physical labor needed to feed one’s family lawfully excuses a worker from the Church’s fast.

Consequence

In Secunda Secundae Question 133, Article 1, faintheartedness copies the servant in Matthew 25 who buried his master’s talent in the dirt. In Question 147, Article 4, fasting never aims to ruin health or duty, excusing youths, the sick, pilgrims, and hard laborers.

Virtues: Justice, Fortitude, Humility

Evidence