Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

Decision case · Saint Thomas Aquinas

Limits of Human Obedience and Higher Fairness in an Emergency

Context

Two cases come before you. First, a powerful lord claims obedience requires his servant and grown son to marry or stay single strictly at his order. Second, city law forbids opening the town gates before sunrise. At dawn, an enemy ambush traps the city’s own defenders outside the walls unless the keeper opens the gate at once. Using Question 104 and Question 120, how will you rule?

Options

  • Leave marriage and virginity free from masters or parents, and apply equity (epikeia) to open the gate and save the defenders.
  • Order blind obedience to the lord’s marriage commands, and leave the city’s defenders to die outside the locked gate.

Choice

Human obedience covers outward duties alone, leaving marriage and virginity free under God. In a sudden crisis where the bare wording of a law would harm the common good, equity (epikeia)—higher fairness—follows the lawmaker’s true intent.

Consequence

In Secunda Secundae Question 104, Article 5, in inner choices and bodily life—such as marriage or virginity—humans answer to God alone. In Question 120, Article 1, opening besieged gates to save defenders fulfills higher justice above the bare letter.

Virtues: Justice, Fortitude, Humility

Evidence