Decision case · Saint Thomas Aquinas
Hidden Flaws in Trade and Bread Taken in Extreme Famine
Context
A wealthy merchant brings you two cases. First, he wants to sell a secretly sick horse and a house with rotting beams at full price without warning buyers. Second, during a deadly winter famine, a starving mother took one loaf from his full storehouse to save her dying child. The merchant demands she be condemned for mortal theft. How will you rule on both cases?
Options
- Rule that hiding serious flaws at full price is fraud requiring repayment, while taking bread in extreme starvation is lawful, not theft.
- Approve selling the sick horse and rotting house at full price secretly, and condemn the starving mother as a thief.
Choice
Sellers must reveal hidden defects or lower the price fairly, or else repay the buyer’s loss. Meanwhile, in clear, urgent extreme need, taking what is strictly required to save human life is lawful and not theft.
Consequence
In Secunda Secundae Question 77, Article 3, hiding a broken-winded horse or tottering house cheats the buyer and demands repayment. In Question 66, Article 7, property laws never cancel natural law, under which earthly goods exist to keep people alive.
Virtues: Justice, Fortitude, Humility
