Decision case · Saint Thomas Aquinas
Why Civil Law Must Not Outlaw Every Minor Moral Fault
Context
Eager royal advisers propose a sweeping civil code that punishes every moral fault with fines and prison. Every small lie, flash of impatience, extra dish at table, or stingy mood would become a state crime. Since God’s law forbids every sin, they argue civil law must outlaw every sin too. How will you advise the king and council on the wise limits of human law?
Options
- Advise that human law governs imperfect citizens and should ban chiefly grave harms like murder and theft, leaving lesser sins to God’s law.
- Back the advisers’ plan to punish every minor fault and private weakness through state police power.
Choice
Human civil law should forbid only the graver vices—above all crimes like murder and theft that harm neighbors and wreck public peace. Leading citizens toward virtue step by step, civil law leaves the total ban on all sins to Divine Law.
Consequence
In Prima Secundae Question 96, Article 2, laws must match the people they govern, as rules for children differ from rules for adults. Crushing imperfect citizens under total police bans breeds worse outbreaks, like new wine bursting old skins.
Virtues: Charity, Moral Prudence, Fidelity to Natural Law
