Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

Decision case · Saint Thomas Aquinas

Healing Deep Grief and Answering Harsh Stoic Scorn for Emotion

Context

A young friar in your priory is crushed by grief after a sudden loss and heavy exhaustion. Strict brothers scold him whenever he weeps or seeks kind friends, calling every emotion of sorrow a moral sickness. They demand that he crush all feeling by sheer willpower without rest or comfort. How will you correct those harsh brothers and care for the grieving friar?

Options

  • Show that emotions guided by reason fit human virtue, and apply five remedies: prayerful truth, kind friends, tears, rest, and bodily care.
  • Agree with the Stoic brothers that tears, friendship, and rest are moral failures, forbidding all comfort.

Choice

Against harsh Stoicism, moderate emotions belong to healthy human nature and Christian virtue. Five remedies gently heal human sorrow: contemplating truth, sharing grief with friends, weeping, honest refreshment, and sleep or warm baths.

Consequence

In Prima Secundae Questions 24 and 38, Christ Himself and the saints felt virtuous sorrow and compassion. Because humans unite soul and body, spiritual truth, loyal friendship, tears, and bodily rest rightly work together to heal grief.

Virtues: Charity, Moral Prudence, Fidelity to Natural Law

Evidence