Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

Decision case · Saint Thomas Aquinas

Judging the Binding Force and Guilt of a Mistaken Conscience

Context

Two moral puzzles come before you. First, a student mistakenly thinks playing a harmless weekday game is a mortal sin, yet friends urge him to play against his conscience. Second, a judge refuses to learn basic rules of fair trials and condemns an innocent prisoner, claiming his ignorant conscience felt fine. Under Question 19 of the Prima Secundae, how will you judge both cases?

Options

  • Rule that acting against conscience is always sinful, while following a mistaken conscience excuses only when the ignorance is not negligent.
  • Advise the student to ignore his conscience when friends push him, and excuse the careless judge because he felt no guilt.

Choice

Acting against even a mistaken conscience is always sinful because the will consents to what reason presents as evil. Yet following a mistaken conscience excuses from sin only when the error is free from careless neglect.

Consequence

In Prima Secundae Question 19 (Articles 5 and 6), going against conscience always wills evil. Still, willful or lazy ignorance of duties one ought to know never excuses, so a careless judge remains guilty and must correct his error.

Virtues: Charity, Moral Prudence, Fidelity to Natural Law

Evidence