Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

Decision case · Saint Thomas Aquinas

Defending Personal Responsibility Against Astrology and One-Mind Theories

Context

Two fashionable theories are spreading among university students. First, astrologers claim the stars at birth force a person into crime or virtue. Second, followers of Averroes claim all humans share one single thinking mind outside individual people. Several students conclude that individuals bear no moral blame for their sins. How will you refute both claims and defend personal responsibility?

Options

  • Prove each person’s rational soul is his own body’s life-principle, while stars touch only bodily moods that free reason can master.
  • Concede that planetary alignments force the human will unless a miracle steps in.

Choice

Each person owns an individual thinking soul as the substantial form—the inner life-principle—of his body. Heavenly bodies can stir bodily moods indirectly, yet they can never force free human choice.

Consequence

In Chapters LXXVI and CXV, one shared mind for everyone would destroy personal thought and moral life. Because intellect and will have no physical organs, stars cannot rule them directly; wise people govern bodily moods by free will.

Virtues: Sacred Doctrine, Wisdom, Trust in Divine Providence

Evidence