Decision case · Saint Thomas Aquinas
Judging Two Early Christian Readings of the Six Days of Creation
Context
During a university lecture on Genesis 1, two groups of students clash sharply. One side follows Basil, Gregory, and John Chrysostom, holding that God made sky, plants, stars, and animals across six calendar days. The other side follows Augustine, holding that God made all things at once in seed-principles while six 'days' mark angelic knowledge. Each camp demands that you condemn the rival Church Fathers as false teachers against the faith. How will you settle this dispute?
Options
- Show how both Augustine’s all-at-once view and Basil’s six-successive-days view uphold God’s creation without condemning either saint.
- Condemn one of the two early Christian traditions as false teaching and ban students from reading it.
Choice
Thomas preserves both Saint Augustine’s simultaneous-order reading and Saint Basil’s successive-days reading of Genesis 1. Both explanations faithfully guard the Catholic doctrine that God created all things.
Consequence
Across Chapters LXVI to LXXIV, Thomas places Augustine beside Basil, Ambrose, and John Chrysostom. Basil’s six-day view fits the plain wording for popular preaching, Augustine’s shields Scripture from scoffers, and both keep the faith whole.
Virtues: Sacred Doctrine, Wisdom, Trust in Divine Providence
