Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

Decision case · Saint Thomas Aquinas

Guarding the Mystery of the Trinity Against Overreaching Proofs

Context

Several preachers notice how the human mind forms an inner word and breathes forth love. Excited by that comparison, they want to announce in public debate that natural philosophy alone strictly proves the Trinity without Scripture. How will you guide these preachers so they protect both Christian credibility and the supernatural gift of revealed faith?

Options

  • Forbid claiming that natural reason strictly proves the Trinity, using mind-and-love comparisons only to show faith is not contradictory.
  • Approve presenting the comparison of human thought and love as an inescapable philosophical proof of the Trinity.

Choice

The Trinity must be held as a revealed mystery of faith and never presented as provable by natural reason alone. Weak claims of strict proof would only invite unbelievers to mock Christian faith.

Consequence

In Chapter XXXII, natural reason knows God from creatures only in the unity of His one Essence. Claiming to prove the Trinity by reason cheapens a supernatural mystery and makes unbelievers think Christians rest on weak arguments.

Virtues: Sacred Doctrine, Wisdom, Trust in Divine Providence

Evidence