Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

Decision case · Saint Thomas Aquinas

Praying the Fifth Petition After Suffering an Injury

Context

A Christian wronged by a neighbor asks your counsel about the Fifth Petition of the Lord’s Prayer. That line asks God to forgive our trespasses as we forgive those who trespass against us. The offender has not asked pardon yet, and the hurt man has not gone out first. Some tell him to skip or change those words when praying the Our Father lest he condemn himself. Others claim he cannot be saved unless he seeks out the offender right away before being asked. Dropping Christ’s words or keeping hatred forfeits mercy, yet turning saintly perfection into a universal law burdens consciences.

Options

  • Forbid dropping Christ’s words, require banishing hatred and forgiving when asked, and commend seeking the offender first as saintly perfection.
  • Advise him to skip 'as we forgive them that trespass against us' until every hurt feeling disappears.
  • Claim that anyone who sins or feels anger after Baptism can never receive God’s pardon even through repentance.

Choice

In Exposition XVI–XVII, Saint Thomas refuted Novatian’s heresy, a false teaching rejected by the Church, and forbade skipping Christ’s words. Every Christian must banish heart-hatred and forgive whenever asked. Going first to win over an unrepentant offender belongs to the higher perfection of the saints.

Consequence

By forgiving from the heart and praying the full Our Father with the Church, the believer lives out Christ’s promise. As Jesus Beatitude pledges, the merciful shall obtain mercy.

Virtues: Counsel, Wisdom, Humility

Evidence