Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

Decision case · Saint Thomas Aquinas

Sacramental Confession and True Relief for Souls in Purgatory

Context

A grieving son whose father recently died brings two urgent questions to you. Months ago he fell into a grave mortal sin and asked God’s pardon privately in his room. First, he asks whether he may now receive Holy Communion without confessing that mortal sin to a priest. Second, he asks whether offering Mass for his late father truly helps his soul in Purgatory. How will you counsel him?

Options

  • Require sacramental Confession to a priest before Communion, and commend the Mass, prayers, alms, and indulgences for Purgatory.
  • Let him receive Communion at once without Confession, and claim prayers of the living cannot help the dead.

Choice

Every mortal sin committed after Baptism must be brought to sacramental Confession before a believer receives Holy Communion. At the same time, the Mass, prayers, alms, and indulgences of the living directly relieve souls in Purgatory.

Consequence

In Third Part Chapters XXXIV, XXXIX, and XLIV, receiving the Eucharist in unconfessed mortal sin commits grave sacrilege. Even deep sorrow includes the resolve to confess, while the Church’s Eucharistic sacrifice and prayers bring sure relief to the departed.

Virtues: Sacred Doctrine, Theological Virtues, Sacramental Fidelity

Evidence