Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

Decision case · Saint Thomas Aquinas

Why Denying One Article of Faith Destroys Supernatural Faith

Context

A university scholar tells you he gladly accepts almost every Catholic teaching, including the Trinity, the Incarnation, and Christ’s Resurrection. Yet he stubbornly rejects one defined Church doctrine because it clashes with his personal philosophy. Even so, he insists he still keeps supernatural faith in all the other teachings he likes. How will you show what stubbornly denying one article does to faith?

Options

  • Show that stubbornly rejecting even one Church-taught article destroys supernatural faith, turning the rest into mere personal opinion.
  • Reassure him that he keeps supernatural faith in the remaining teachings so long as he accepts most of the Creed.

Choice

Stubbornly rejecting even one defined article of faith destroys the supernatural virtue of faith altogether. Whoever picks and chooses doctrines holds the remaining truths by private human opinion rather than God’s authority.

Consequence

In Secunda Secundae Question 5, Article 3, true faith rests on God’s revealing authority as proposed by the Church. Picking which revealed truths to accept replaces God’s word with self-will and loses supernatural faith completely.

Virtues: Sacred Doctrine, Theological Virtues, Sacramental Fidelity

Evidence