Decision case · Saint Thomas Aquinas
Judging Good Intentions with Bad Means and Unjust Human Laws
Context
Two moral cases are brought to you for judgment. First, a rich merchant wants to fake a customs tax form and give the saved money to a poor orphanage. Second, a local judge asks whether citizens must obey a new civil decree that directly breaks God’s commandment. How will you rule on both cases?
Options
- Rule that a good goal never makes an evil act good, and a human decree against God’s law never binds conscience.
- Allow the merchant’s tax fraud for charity, and command citizens to obey every civil law even against God.
Choice
A human act becomes morally evil whenever its action, its goal, or its circumstances go wrong. Moreover, human decrees that command anything against God’s law lose the force of law and must never be obeyed.
Consequence
In Prima Secundae Chapters IV and XVII, no noble motive can turn a dishonest deed into a good act. Human law binds conscience only when it fits right reason, for against unjust commands 'we must obey God rather than men'.
Virtues: Sacred Doctrine, Theological Virtues, Sacramental Fidelity
