Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

Decision case · Saint Thomas Aquinas

Guiding a Troubled Believer Between Despair and Presumption

Context

After a parish lesson on God’s providence and predestination, an anxious believer comes to speak with you. If God eternally knows the exact number of the saved, he worries that human effort is pointless. Either he is already chosen and need not fight sin, or he is lost and all his prayers are wasted. How will you protect him from both despair and moral carelessness?

Options

  • Show that God hides predestination to keep us humble, while ordaining prayer and good works as the real path to glory.
  • Urge him to seek an inner feeling of certainty that he cannot lose salvation no matter how he lives.

Choice

Because God hides who is predestined and makes prayer and good works the ordained path to heaven, believers shun despair and presumption alike. Every Christian must pray and strive with firm hope in God’s help.

Consequence

In First Part Chapter IX of the Summa Catechism, nobody knows his final destiny, preventing careless pride and hopeless despair. God never forces anyone into sin, and our prayers, alms, and good works carry out God’s saving plan.

Virtues: Sacred Doctrine, Theological Virtues, Sacramental Fidelity

Evidence