Decision case · Saint Alphonsus Liguori
Judging a Candidate's Fitness for the Priesthood
Context
A young seminary student asks your approval to be ordained a priest. He studies well enough, and his parents are pushing him hard to be ordained. They want to keep a family-linked Church income post from going to outsiders. Examining his conscience, however, you find he is entering mainly to please his parents and keep up family status. Worse, he has not yet won steady, long-tested victory over repeated sins against purity, hoping ordination itself will cure him later. Ordaining an uncalled, untested man endangers both him and his flock, while refusing him angers his family. How will you judge his fitness for the priesthood?
Options
- Forbid him to take Sacred Orders until he proves a pure desire to serve God alone and wins long-tested victory over habitual sin beforehand. Also warn his parents against forcing him into the priesthood.
- Allow him to be ordained now, hoping the dignity and sacramental grace of priesthood will cure his repeated sins afterward.
- Approve his ordination on the ground that good grades and keeping the family Church income are enough signs of a calling.
Choice
In Sections I–III of 'The Vocation to the Priesthood', St. Alphonsus proves that family income, parental pressure, and talent never make a divine call. A candidate must have all three true marks together: pure intention, sound theology, and proven virtue. Confessors must refuse absolution both to untested men entering Orders in habitual sin and to parents who push them.
Consequence
Holding strictly to those three marks protects the altar from unworthy ministers and saves uncalled youths and their families from eternal ruin.
Virtues: Vocation Discernment, Moral Prudence, Pastoral Charity
