Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

Decision case · Saint Alphonsus Liguori

Guiding a Young Student Torn Between the World and the Cloister

Context

A young graduate comes to you deeply unsure about what path in life to choose. His talents and family ties open doors to government posts or wealthy Church benefices—offices carrying guaranteed income—though he fears surrounding moral dangers. At the same time, he feels drawn to the safety of a religious house. Yet he worries his health may fail under the rule, or thinks he can do good staying at home. Choosing from worldly ambition risks eternal ruin, whereas choosing God's will brings the graces needed for salvation. What practical method will you give this undecided student to choose rightly?

Options

  • Direct him to make the Spiritual Exercises in strict silence and set aside all desire for worldly honors. Tell him to choose the state of life he will wish he had chosen on his deathbed before Christ's judgment.
  • Advise him to try a worldly career or Church income post first to test whether he keeps his spiritual zeal amid business.
  • Tell him to decide solely by whether his body feels strong enough for harsh penances, without making a silent retreat.

Choice

St. Alphonsus gives this rule in 'Answer to a Young Man', 'Advice to a Young Person in Doubt', and 'Letter to a Young Student'. The youth must make a silent retreat with the Spiritual Exercises, putting aside worldly ambition and false health fears. He should choose what he will wish to have chosen at death before Christ's judgment seat.

Consequence

The student weighs the world and the monastery from the viewpoint of his deathbed while praying silently to Jesus and Mary. In that way, he settles his doubt solely for the salvation of his soul.

Virtues: Vocation Discernment, Moral Prudence, Detachment

Evidence