Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

Decision case · Saint Alphonsus Liguori

Obeying a Religious Call When Parents Will Oppose It

Context

A young man living at home feels a clear inner call from God to leave the world and enter a religious order. His parents have plenty of means and do not need his work to survive. Yet he knows that out of natural affection and worldly plans, they will fiercely oppose his leaving if they find out. He asks whether respect for parents requires him to tell them and wait for permission before entering the novitiate, the training year for new members. Or should he keep his plan secret and obey God's call promptly? Delaying or facing family tears and pressure risks snuffing out the delicate grace of vocation and endangering eternal salvation.

Options

  • Advise him to keep his calling secret from parents and friends, sharing it only with his spiritual director. Urge him to pray quietly until he can enter the enclosed monastery, or cloister, without delay.
  • Tell him to inform his parents at once and put off entering the monastery until they gladly give their blessing.
  • Recommend dropping the monastery plan altogether and trying to live like a monk privately inside his father's house.

Choice

Following St. Thomas Aquinas, St. Jerome, St. Bernard, and St. John Chrysostom, St. Alphonsus gives clear counsel. When parents are not in extreme need, one called to religion must obey God promptly without asking parental permission. He should keep his plan secret from relatives while praying quietly.

Consequence

Alphonsus points to saints like Thomas Aquinas and Francis Xavier, who bypassed family interference to follow God. By contrast, youths who delayed or gave in to relatives lost both their calling and their souls.

Virtues: Vocation Discernment, Detachment, Perseverance

Evidence