Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

Catholic Saints · Low Hall, near Knaresborough, Yorkshire

  • Venerable
  • Feast 5 August
  • d. 5 August (or 8 October) 1585, York
  • 3 sources
Mosaic portrait of Venerable Robert Bickerdike

Venerable Robert Bickerdike (d. 1585)

Also known as Robert Bickerdike

Why was Venerable Robert Bickerdike condemned and executed at York in 1585?

Venerable Robert Bickerdike (died 5 August or 8 October 1585), a Yorkshire layman born at Low Hall near Knaresborough and residing at York, was arrested for buying a glass of ale for the priest Venerable John Boste and for defending Venerable Francis Ingleby, and suffered martyrdom at York.1

Life and remembrance

Traditional account

Venerable Robert Bickerdike (died 5 August or 8 October 1585) was a Yorkshire layman born at Low Hall near Knaresborough and residing in the city of York. Arrested for having given a glass of ale to the missionary priest Venerable John Boste, he was also charged at his trial with having spoken treasonable words: when the priest Venerable Francis Ingleby was being dragged on a hurdle to execution and a minister's wife exclaimed, "Let us go into the Tolbooth and we shall see the traitorly thief come over on the hurdle," Bickerdike had replied, "No; no thief, but as true as thou art."1

Although Bickerdike was acquitted at his first trial in the city, Judge Rhodes—determined to secure his death—had him transferred from the city gaol to York Castle and tried a second time on the same charge at the Lammas Assizes, where he was condemned and executed at York.1

A contemporary manuscript relation by the Reverend Ralph Fisher, preserved in missionary memoirs and summarized in the English menology for 8 October, records that when Bickerdike was brought before the York magistrates for having been reconciled to the Roman Church and refusing to attend Protestant services, he was interrogated on what course he would take if the Pope or the King of Spain invaded England, to which he answered that if any such thing came to pass he would do as God should put him in mind. Arraigned first for treason upon that reply at the Common Hall of the city of York, he was found not guilty by conscientious jurors, whereupon Judge Francis Rhodes transferred him from the city gaol to York Castle, empaneled a second jury on a fresh indictment, and sentenced him to be hanged, drawn, and quartered; manuscript calendars record his execution date variously as 23 July, 5 August, or 8 October (when he is commemorated in the English menology alongside the Tyburn priest-martyrs John Lowe, John Adams, and Richard Dibdale).34

Other accounts and ways this saint is remembered

Primary and secondary authorities on Venerable Robert Bickerdike include John Bridgewater (Aquepontanus), Concertatio Ecclesiae Catholicae in Anglia (Trier, 1589); John Morris, The Catholics of York under Elizabeth (London, 1891); and Memoirs of Missionary Priests.2

Remember

  • Born at Low Hall near Knaresborough and living at York, Venerable Robert Bickerdike was arrested for giving a glass of ale to the priest Venerable John Boste.1
  • He was also charged with treasonable words for replying to a minister's wife that Venerable Francis Ingleby, then being dragged on the hurdle to execution, was 'no thief, but as true as thou art.'1
  • After Bickerdike was acquitted at his first trial, Judge Rhodes removed him from the city gaol to York Castle and had him retried and condemned on the same charge at the Lammas Assizes.1
  • He suffered martyrdom at York on 5 August (or 8 October) 1585.134

Check yourself

For what act toward Venerable John Boste and what defence of Venerable Francis Ingleby was Robert Bickerdike arrested, and which judge ordered him retried at the Lammas Assizes after his initial acquittal?

Writings and words

“No; no thief, but as true as thou art.”

vol. II, p. 558 (clean-text lines 91879–91880)

Feast days and patronage

  • 5 August — English Martyrs Martyrology (alternative date 8 October) (York, England · memorial)

Facts and sources

Each fact names its source. The label shows how sure we can be.

  1. The Church status of Venerable Robert Bickerdike is Venerable.

    Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume II: Assize–Brownsonvol. II, p. 558 (clean-text lines 91864–91865)

  2. Born at Low Hall near Knaresborough and residing at York, the layman Robert Bickerdike suffered martyrdom at York on 5 August (or 8 October) 1585.

    Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume II: Assize–Brownsonvol. II, p. 558 (clean-text lines 91864–91881)

  3. Arrested for giving a glass of ale to the priest Venerable John Boste and accused of treasonable words for defending Venerable Francis Ingleby on the hurdle ('No; no thief, but as true as thou art'), Bickerdike was acquitted once, removed by Judge Rhodes from the city gaol to York Castle, and condemned at the Lammas Assizes.

    Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume II: Assize–Brownsonvol. II, p. 558 (clean-text lines 91868–91885)

  4. In the manuscript relation of the Reverend Ralph Fisher, Robert Bickerdike of Low Hall near Knaresborough answered the York magistrate's question concerning a hypothetical invasion by the Pope or the King of Spain by saying he would do as God should put him in mind, was acquitted by a conscientious jury at the city hall, and was removed by Judge Rhodes to York Castle where a new jury condemned him to be hanged, drawn, and quartered.

    Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceMemoirs of Missionary Priests, and Other Catholics of Both Sexes, that Have Suffered Death in England on Religious Accounts from the Year 1577 to 1684Richard Challoner, Memoirs of Missionary Priests, Pt. I (1586), Robert Bickerdike, Gentleman, lines 7663-7698

  5. In the menology of England and Wales for 8 October, Venerable Robert Bickerdike is commemorated at York for suffering death after refusing Protestant worship and answering that in the event of an invasion he would do as God should put him in mind.

    Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceA Menology of England and Wales; or, Brief Memorials of the Ancient British and English Saints Arranged According to the Calendar, Together with the Martyrs of the 16th and 17th CenturiesRichard Stanton, A Menology of England and Wales (1892), 8 October, Venerable Robert Bickerdike, lines 23752-23765

Sources

Bede Camm, “Bickerdike, Venerable,” The Catholic Encyclopedia (1907), vol. II, p. 558. About this source

Notes and sources

  1. 1. Camm records Bickerdike's birth at Low Hall near Knaresborough, residence at York, arrest for giving a glass of ale to Ven. John Boste, acquittal and second trial at the Lammas Assizes under Judge Rhodes, defence of Ven. Francis Ingleby on the hurdle, and martyrdom at York on 5 August or 8 October 1585.

    1. Birth at Low Hall near Knaresborough, arrest for aiding John Boste, retrial under Judge Rhodes, and defence of Francis InglebyLines 91864–91882

    Original passage

    “Bickerdike, Robert, Venerable, martyr, a Yorkshire layman, b. at Low Hall, near Knares- borough (date unknown), but residing at York; d. 5 August (or 8 October), 1585. Arrested”
  2. 2. Cited bibliography for Pass 2: Bridgewater, Concertatio (Trier, 1589); Morris, The Catholics of York under Elizabeth (London, 1891); Challoner, Memoirs of Missionary Priests.

    2. Primary and secondary bibliography on Venerable Robert BickerdikeLines 91881–91885

    Original passage

    “the cause of his death. He suffered at York. Bhidgewater, Concertatio (Trier, 15S9): Morris, The Catholics of York under Elizabeth (London, 1891); Challoner, Me7noirs. BeDE CaMM.”
  3. 3. Preserves the Reverend Ralph Fisher's manuscript relation of Bickerdike's examination on the invasion question ('he would then do as God should put him in mind'), his initial acquittal at the city hall, his removal by Judge Rhodes from the city gaol to York Castle for a second indictment, and the alternative manuscript dates of 23 July and 8 October.

    3. Ralph Fisher's manuscript relation on the papal invasion question, acquittal at the city hall, retrial at York Castle under Judge Rhodes, and the 23 July / 8 October datesLines 7663–7698

    About this source edition

    Richard Challoner, Memoirs of Missionary Priests, Pt. I (1586), Robert Bickerdike, Gentleman, lines 7663-7698

    Original passage

    “The reverend Mr. Ralph Fisher, in a manuscript relation, which I have in my hands, recounts the following particulars of him. ‘ Robert Bickerdike, gentleman, was bom in Yorkshire, near to the town of Knaresborough ; but his dwelling was in the city of York ; who being brought before the magistrate there for matter of conscience and reli- gion, was examined, among other things, if the pope, or his agent, the king of Spain, should invade England, whether he would take the queen’s part, or the pope’s ? To this Mr. Bickerdike did make answer, if any such thing came to pass, he would then do as God should put him in mind.”
  4. 4. Commemorates Venerable Robert Bickerdike on 8 October alongside the Tyburn martyrs John Lowe, John Adams, and Richard Dibdale, recounting his answer to the invasion question, his initial acquittal, and his retrial at York Castle.

    4. 8 October menology commemoration at York of Venerable Robert BickerdikeLines 23757–23765

    About this source edition

    Richard Stanton, A Menology of England and Wales (1892), 8 October, Venerable Robert Bickerdike, lines 23757-23765

    Original passage

    “the charge of having been reconciled to the Church of Rome, and refusing to attend the Protestant worship. He was questioned as to what he would do if the Pope or the King of Spain should invade the kingdom ; to which he replied that he " should do as God should put him in mind ".”

Found an error? Report a correction.