Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

Catholic Saints · Isle of Wight

  • Venerable
  • Feast 25 April
  • d. 25 April 1586 on the Isle of Wight
  • 3 sources
Mosaic portrait of Venerable Robert Anderton

Venerable Robert Anderton (c. 1560–1586)

Also known as Venerable Robert Anderton

Why were Venerable Robert Anderton and William Marsden examined in London before their execution?

Venerable Robert Anderton (born around 1560, executed 25 April 1586) was an Oxford-educated English convert ordained at Reims in 1580. Cast ashore on the Isle of Wight in a storm with William Marsden, he refused the "bloody question" in London and suffered martyrdom.12

Life and remembrance

Traditional account

Venerable Robert Anderton, an English priest and martyr, was born on the Isle of Wight around 1560 and matriculated at Brasenose College, Oxford, in 1578. Travelling afterward to the Continent, he was received into the Catholic Church and entered the English College at Reims in 1580, where he formed an unbroken companionship with his fellow seminarian William Marsden.1

Upon completing their priestly studies, Anderton and Marsden set sail for England in 1586. Overwhelmed by a violent storm at sea, they prayed that they might die on land rather than by drowning, and when their vessel was driven ashore they were immediately arrested, tried, and condemned to death. Because they pleaded at their trial that they had not transgressed the statute against seminary priests intentionally, having been cast ashore by force of weather, they were summoned to London for examination.12

In London the two priests were interrogated upon the "bloody question"—whether they would take up arms against the Pope in a war fought for purely religious causes. Although both acknowledged Queen Elizabeth I as their lawful sovereign in all temporal matters, they refused to subscribe to the test. Their death sentences were confirmed, a royal proclamation was published setting forth their offence, and they were carried back and hanged, drawn, and quartered on 25 April 1586 near the spot where the storm had cast them ashore.2

In the Douai and Reims college records Anderton is also associated with an honourable family of the county palatine of Lancaster, while his companion William Marsden was born in the parish of Goosnargh in the same county. At Reims Anderton earned the reputation of a scholar of distinguished learning (vir doctissimus), and according to the college journal he received priestly ordination at Laon. When their ship was driven ashore on the Isle of Wight and they were brought before a local justice of the peace, the two priests did not deny their sacred orders, and at their trial they demonstrated that they had been cast ashore against their will and had not remained in England for the number of days specified in the statute against seminary priests. Although this legal plea was overruled by the court, the constancy and cheerfulness with which Anderton and Marsden met their execution on the Isle of Wight on 25 April 1586 edified the Catholics present and astonished their adversaries.34

Remember

  • Born on the Isle of Wight around 1560, Venerable Robert Anderton matriculated at Brasenose College, Oxford, in 1578, converted abroad, and entered the English College at Reims in 1580 with William Marsden.1
  • Driven ashore by a storm while sailing to England, Anderton and Marsden were arrested and pleaded that they had been cast on land involuntarily.12
  • Summoned to London and examined on the "bloody question," they acknowledged Elizabeth I in all temporal matters but refused to pledge to fight against the Pope in a religious war.2
  • Following a royal proclamation confirming their sentence, both priests were hanged, drawn, and quartered near their landing site on 25 April 1586.12

Check yourself

What defence did Venerable Robert Anderton and William Marsden raise at their initial trial after their ship was driven ashore in a storm?

Feast days and patronage

  • 25 April — Martyrology of English and Welsh Martyrs (England (Isle of Wight) · memorial)

Virtues

Facts and sources

Each fact names its source. The label shows how sure we can be.

  1. The Church status of Venerable Robert Anderton is Venerable.

    Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume I: Aachen–Assizevol. I, p. 467 (clean-text lines 78731–78732)

  2. Born on the Isle of Wight around 1560, Anderton matriculated at Brasenose College, Oxford, in 1578, converted to Catholicism abroad, and entered the English College at Reims in 1580 alongside William Marsden.

    Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume I: Aachen–Assizevol. I, p. 467 (clean-text lines 78731–78738)

  3. Cast ashore by a storm while sailing to England, Anderton and Marsden pleaded that they had landed perforce, were summoned to London, and acknowledged Elizabeth I in temporal matters while refusing the "bloody question."

    Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume I: Aachen–Assizevol. I, p. 467 (clean-text lines 78738–78752)

  4. Robert Anderton and William Marsden were hanged, drawn, and quartered near their landing site on 25 April 1586.

    Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume I: Aachen–Assizevol. I, p. 467 (clean-text lines 78732–78756)

  5. Primary bibliography cited for Pass 2: Richard Challoner, Memoirs of Missionary Priests; John Hungerford Pollen, Acts of English Martyrs (1891), 66–82.

    Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume I: Aachen–Assizevol. I, p. 467 (clean-text lines 78758–78759)

  6. Remembered in the Reims manuscript history as a man of great learning (vir doctissimus) and ordained at Laon according to the college journal, Robert Anderton pleaded with William Marsden of Goosnargh that they had been cast ashore on the Isle of Wight against their will and had not remained in England the number of days specified in the statute.

    Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceMemoirs of Missionary Priests, and Other Catholics of Both Sexes, that Have Suffered Death in England on Religious Accounts from the Year 1577 to 1684Richard Challoner, Memoirs of Missionary Priests, Pt. I (1586), Robert Anderton and William Marsden, lines 7361-7405

  7. Executed on the Isle of Wight on 25 April 1586 after their statutory defence was disregarded, Robert Anderton and William Marsden met death with a constancy and cheerfulness that edified the Catholics present and astonished their adversaries.

    Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceA Menology of England and Wales; or, Brief Memorials of the Ancient British and English Saints Arranged According to the Calendar, Together with the Martyrs of the 16th and 17th CenturiesRichard Stanton, A Menology of England and Wales (1892), 25 April, lines 9284-9304

Sources

Patrick Ryan, “Anderton, Venerable,” The Catholic Encyclopedia (1907), vol. I, p. 467. About this source

Notes and sources

  1. 1. Robert Anderton (born on the Isle of Wight c. 1560, died 25 April 1586) matriculated at Brasenose College, Oxford, in 1578, converted abroad, entered Reims in 1580 with William Marsden, and was cast ashore in a storm upon returning to England.

    1. Birth on the Isle of Wight, Oxford matriculation (1578), Reims seminary (1580), and shipwreck with MarsdenLines 78731–78745

    Original passage

    “Anderton, Robert, Venerable, an English priest and martyr, b. in the Isle of Wight about 1.560; d. 25 .\pril, 15.S6. He matriculated at Brasenose College, Oxford, in 1578. He afterwards went abroad, was converted, and then entered the college} at Reims in 1.580. It was there that he and .Marsden began that companionship which was not broken even in death. Having completed their course, they set sail for England, but were overwhelmed in :i storm. They prayed that they might die on land rather than on sea, and their prayer was grante<l. Driven ashore, they were at once seized and shortly after tried and condemned. They now pleaded thai they had not tran.sgres.sed the statute, as they had been cast on shore perforce. This led to their being”
  2. 2. Examined in London on the 'bloody question', Anderton and Marsden acknowledged Elizabeth as lawful queen in temporal matters but refused the test, and were hanged, drawn, and quartered near where they had landed on 25 April 1586. Pass 2 bibliography cited by Patrick Ryan: Richard Challoner, Memoirs of Missionary Priests; John Hungerford Pollen, Acts of English Martyrs (London, 1891), pp. 66–82.

    2. Examination in London on the 'bloody question', execution (25 April 1586), and bibliographyLines 78745–78761

    Original passage

    “been cast on shore perforce. This led to their being summoned to London, where they were examined upon the celebrated "bloody question", whether they would fight against the Pope, even if tlic quarrel were for purely religious causes. Though they acknowledged Elizabeth as their lawful queen in all temporal matters, they would not consent to the required test. The sentence was then confirmed, and a proclamation was published explaining their guilt. They were taken back and executed near the place where they had l)een cast ashore, being hanged, drawn, and quartered. CnALLONFR. Memoirs; Pollen, .\cts of English Martyrs (18911, 60-82. Patrick Ryax.”
  3. 3. Records the Douai catalogue tradition connecting Anderton with an honourable Lancashire family and William Marsden with Goosnargh, notes Anderton's reputation as vir doctissimus and his ordination at Laon, and details their overruled plea that they had not remained in the kingdom the number of days required by the statute.

    3. Lancashire family attribution, reputation as vir doctissimus, ordination at Laon, and statutory defence on the Isle of WightLines 7361–7405

    About this source edition

    Richard Challoner, Memoirs of Missionary Priests, Pt. I (1586), Robert Anderton and William Marsden, lines 7361-7405

    Original passage

    “Robert Anderton, bom of an honourable family in the county pala- tine of Lancaster, and William Marsden, bom in the parish of Goosenor, in the same county ; both performed their studies in the college of Rhemes : and Mr. Anderton, in particular, has the character, in the manuscript history, of having been a man of great learning, t nr docti* - simm.”
  4. 4. Confirms the Reims tradition of Anderton's learning (vir doctissimus), their statutory defence after being driven by a storm onto the Isle of Wight, and the astonishment of their adversaries at their cheerfulness in death.

    4. Menology notice of Anderton and Marsden's trial plea and constancy at execution on 25 April 1586Lines 9284–9304

    About this source edition

    Richard Stanton, A Menology of England and Wales (1892), 25 April, lines 9284-9304

    Original passage

    “They were both students of the English- College at Rheims, where Anderton especially left the reputation of being a man of great learning, vir doctissimus.”

Found an error? Report a correction.